Return Policy

We want you to love every purchase from Come What Mae. Please review the following return policy carefully, as it outlines the terms and conditions for all returns.

RETURN ELIGIBILITY

We offer store credit or refund to original form of payment for approved returns.

To be eligible:

• Items must be postmarked within 14 days of delivery

• Items must be returned in their original condition

All returned items must be:

• Unworn

• Unwashed

• Free of odors (including perfume, smoke, or pet hair)

• In original condition with all tags attached

• 🔒 Squish & Sensory Item Policy

  Squish and sensory items are designed for gentle use and may become damaged if over-handled, stretched, or squeezed excessively.

  These items are not intended for consumption. If punctured, contents may pose a health or safety risk if ingested or exposed to eyes, mouth, or open skin.

  For hygiene and safety reasons, we do not accept returns on any opened, used, or handled items, as they may pose a contamination risk and cannot be resold.

  All squish and sensory items are final sale and not eligible for returns, exchanges, or refunds.

  If your item arrives damaged, please contact us within 48 hours of delivery with photo proof for review.

  By completing your purchase, you agree to these terms.

Come What Mae reserves the right to refuse any return that does not meet these requirements. Any rejected returns will be sent back to the customer at their expense.

FINAL SALE ITEMS

The following items are final sale and are not eligible for return under any circumstances:

• Mystery items

• Jewelry and accessories

• Beauty and personal care products

• Food or edible items

• Items marked “Final Sale”

• Discounted or promotional items

RETURN SHIPPING

• Customers are responsible for all return shipping costs

• Original shipping charges are non-refundable

• Come What Mae does not provide prepaid return labels

We strongly recommend using a trackable shipping method, as Come What Mae is not responsible for lost, delayed, or undelivered return packages.

REFUNDS, STORE CREDIT & RESTOCKING FEE

• Approved returns may be issued as store credit or refunded to the original form of payment

• A 15% restocking fee will be applied to all refunds issued to the original form of payment

• Shipping charges are non-refundable

Come What Mae reserves the right to determine, at its sole discretion, whether a return will be issued as store credit or refunded to the original form of payment.

PROCESSING TIME

Returns are processed within 3–5 business days after delivery to our facility.

Refunds or store credit will be issued only after the returned item has been inspected and approved in accordance with this policy.

STORE CREDIT

• Store credit is non-refundable and cannot be redeemed for cash

• Come What Mae is not responsible for lost or unused store credit

RETURN ADDRESS

Returns should be sent to:

Come What Mae
1156 State Route 33
Farmingdale, NJ 07727

PLEASE INCLUDE YOUR NAME & ORDER NUMBER

ADDITIONAL TERMS

By completing a purchase with Come What Mae, you acknowledge and agree to this return policy.

Come What Mae reserves the right to update or modify this policy at any time without prior notice.